spacer.png, 0 kB

Linux News Flash

Home arrow News arrow Flash Fears of DRM
Flash Fears of DRM PDF Print E-mail
Article Index
Flash Fears of DRM
Page 2


StumbleUpon!

According to an article on newteevee.com, “the Electronic Frontier Foundation is upset about Adobe's efforts to add digital rights management” to the Flash format. This is Adobe's attempt to get in good with the “ad-supported streaming TV market.” The announcement to have Flash DRM came in April by an outside vendor, Widevine. So, what does this mean for Linux and the already lackluster support of Flash Player? We won't even bother going into the potential mess this is going to cause for Flash users in general; how many people are going to be able to take clips of their favorite shows and movies and turn them into YouTube tributes? That aside, will Linux even be able to play these DRM Flash movies? Probably not. It's not like other DRM mediums are well-supported on Linux, if they're supported at all. So, is this “so long and farewell” to Flash for Linux?

The Flash Player on Linux is a terrible, buggy application. There isn't even 64-bit support yet, so most Linux users on 64-bit systems need to either install 32-bit browsers or create wrapper plug-ins for their 32-bit flash player plugin. The Flash Player is so badly supported that I have found that on Adobe's own website, which uses Flash Player for the top level menu doesn't even display correctly on my Ubuntu PC running 32-bit Firefox with Flash player. Is this a joke? The Flash Player they give us doesn't even work correctly with their own website? Shame on Adobe for releasing such a terrible product. Notice in the screen shot below, as I hover over the menu item for “Solutions”; it's completely cut off by the Flash player movie directly beneath it. This is pathetic. I guess my only real "solution" then is to stop using Flash. And now on top of this already buggy, shoddy plug-in, we have to face the possibility of DRM being in Flash? I guess we might as well say goodbye to flash all together.

Maybe, and I hate to say it, we Linux users can expect something better with the Mono project's porting of Microsoft's Silverlight to Linux, known as Moonlight. This isn't what I want; what I want is for Adobe to stop jerking us around and get their act together. They should start porting all of their applications over to Linux.

Adobe, we're sick of Windows; we don't want to virtualize it; we don't want to use Wine to run your applications; we want you to put two and two together and realize that as small as our market share might seem on paper, there's actually quite a lot of us. And every day, our open source products are getting better and better, catching up to your programs (in some cases surpassing them), and before you know it, we won't even remember your name.

Only registered users can write comments.
Please login or register.


Add as favourites (46) | Quote this article on your site | Views: 3285

Comments (11)
RSS comments
1. 05-03-2008 10:26
Gnash
Stop begging and start using Gnash. It's under development, it might not be 100% neat yet, but there's people out there working on it. Let's use, let's report bugs, let's help them get it done! 
 
F@#! Adobe!
Guest
Free as in Freedom
2. 05-03-2008 05:25
Gnash
To hell with adobe, I hate all their products. Including the annoying Acrobat Reader. 
 
I agree! Stop begging and start using Gnash.
Guest
Joco
3. 05-03-2008 06:42
Gnash
DRM is more than just a simple flash player. addin DRM to this, is goin to set precedence, and is going to push our liberties one step back, even if we use gnash 
once again, the closed source world is threating us
Guest
Carlos Ferrabone
4. 05-03-2008 10:25
Gnash
Adobe Flash Player for Linux is a huge piece of SHIT, unfortunately. 
 
I have to use Firefox's extension FlashBlock just to not be annoyed with the lack of transparency in flash-made pages... 
 
F@#! OFF, Adobe.
Guest
vitor
5. 05-03-2008 07:57
There's a lot of anger in the room
Adobe doesn't make the best products. Unfortunately, that hasn't prevented them from becoming the dominant software vendor for a few file formats. I don't know how much products like gnash will help, since they will probably have difficulty working with Flash files pre-packed with DRM.
Registered
Christopher Mead
6. 05-03-2008 08:16
Gnash
Carlos, you're right, but hopefully I don't think DRM is going to succeed. The GNU/Linux community is large enough 
to let its voice be heard. Let's fight by refusing to use any software implemented under DRM.  
Have a look: 
http://www.fsdaily.com/Legal/Nobody_likes_DRM_including_attorneys_for_Microsoft_Real
Guest
Free as in Freedom
7. 05-03-2008 08:34
Second Class Netizens
Ok, I know I'm going to sound like a conspiracy theorist - but what I am about to say is totally feasable. There are a lot of goings on behind the scenes in this software game. With Commercial software, it's all about the money. Convicted monopolists know that in order to maintain their control over the desktop market they have to keep the popular software on their platform. Who's to say that Adobe isn't getting some sort of "incentive" in order to keep from porting their products over to Linux?
Guest
G David Lewis
8. 05-03-2008 17:41
Videos
Why should we need a plug-in to do something basic like play a movie? That should be integral to the browser. Oh, yeah, I know, there are licensing issues with codecs. How about at least a separate plug-in to play a video and do nothing else (maybe that will be a lot easier to debug). The browser would then run that plug-in when the supported video file types are being rendered (in an iframe or the whole frame).
Guest
Phil
9. 05-03-2008 23:18
Please don't spread misinformation
That menu is not rendered by Flash, but by your web browser. Maybe your browser is broken, maybe the script on the website is broken, but its not a Flash problem. 
 
Believe me, I think Flash sucks ass too, but your mininformation isn't helping anyone.
Guest
Anonymous
10. 21-03-2008 03:23
64-bit
There isn't 64 bit support in Windows Vista either, so it's not a matter of segregation as you are suggesting but merely a matter of time.
Guest
Magus


 
< Prev   Next >
spacer.png, 0 kB
Copyright © New Epoch Software LLC 2008. Website by New Epoch Software LLC
All rights reserved. Logos are property of their respective owners.

We use Fedora Linux